Stock buybacks and dividends have been hotly debated topics among investors and analysts. While some see stock buybacks as a valuable way to create value for shareholders, others view them with suspicion, alleging that they can lead to short-term financial gains while neglecting long-term investments and stakeholder interests. This article will explore why tech companies often prefer stock buybacks over giving dividends, the benefits and downsides of buybacks, and the perspectives of renowned investors like Warren Buffett.
What are Stock Buybacks?
A stock buyback, also known as a share repurchase, is when a company repurchases its stock, reducing the total number of shares outstanding. This, in turn, increases the ownership stake of existing shareholders, as they now hold a larger portion of the company. Unlike dividends, which distribute profits directly to shareholders, stock buybacks allow companies to return excess cash to investors and signal confidence in their prospects.
Why Do Tech Companies Prefer Buybacks?
One of the main reasons why tech companies favour stock buybacks is their tax efficiency. When companies pay dividends, shareholders must pay taxes on the dividend income. However, stock buybacks do not trigger immediate tax liabilities for shareholders, making them a more tax-advantaged option.
Stock buybacks can increase earnings per share (EPS) by reducing the number of shares outstanding. With a constant earnings base but fewer shares, the EPS rises, potentially attracting more investors and driving up the stock price.
Buybacks offer companies greater flexibility than dividends. They can be initiated, suspended, or adjusted according to changing circumstances, whereas dividends are typically expected to be maintained at a stable or increasing rate.
Tech companies, especially those with limited profitable investment opportunities, might choose to repurchase shares rather than investing in projects with lower returns. This decision ensures that excess cash is used to benefit shareholders.
Signal of Undervaluation:
A well-executed stock buyback can signal that a company’s management believes its stock is undervalued, which may attract more investors and improve the stock’s performance.
Warren Buffett’s Perspective:
Legendary investor Warren Buffett has been vocal about supporting well-executed stock buybacks. He emphasizes two critical conditions that must be met for him to favour a company’s buyback: First, the company must have enough money to handle its operational and liquidity needs. Second, the shares must be sold at a significant discount to their conservative estimate of intrinsic business value.
Buybacks: The Controversy
Despite their potential benefits, stock buybacks have faced criticism on various fronts:
Covering Up Stock Issuance:
Some critics argue that companies use buybacks to counterbalance the dilution caused by issuing stock-based compensation to executives. This practice could obscure the negative impact of issuing new shares.
Sceptics claim that buybacks are often used to inflate stock prices and executive compensation tied to stock performance.
When buybacks are carried out at inflated stock prices, they become an inefficient use of shareholder capital, creating value destruction.
Critics contend that buybacks can divert money from essential investments, such as research and development, potentially hampering long-term growth.
Tax advantages, EPS enhancement, flexibility, capital allocation, and the potential signal of undervaluation drive tech companies’ preference for stock buybacks over dividends. While buybacks have faced criticism for various reasons, well-executed repurchase programs can benefit long-term shareholders. Investors should carefully assess the motivations behind a company’s buyback decision, its track record of delivering returns, and its broader financial context to determine whether it is a sound investment choice. In today’s dynamic business landscape, understanding the role of buybacks and dividends is crucial for informed decision-making in tech investments.
Working with Panterra Finance
Managing finances can be a daunting task. However, by working with a fractional CFO, companies can gain access to the expert financial guidance and support they need to succeed. Whether it’s financial strategy development, financial reporting and analysis, cash flow management, cost management, or fundraising and investor relations, a fractional CFO can provide valuable support across various financial disciplines. By partnering with a fractional CFO, businesses can position themselves for long-term success and achieve their strategic objectives.
Sam McQuade is the owner here at Panterra Finance. Sam has successfully scaled his decades-old ideas into an innovative full-service Financial Partner Solution for incubators, startups, and emerging business concepts, as well as well-established international companies, corporations and organizations with the introduction of Panterra Finance. During pivotal transitions, the Panterra Finance professional executive team members are equipped to provide an industry-leading concept of an on-demand Fractional CFO. In disrupting the traditional contracted title of CFO, Panterra Finance innovatively offers all its clients thought leadership based on international financial market experiences. Panterra Finance provides a unified global approach to businesses in the Americas, Europe, Asia, and Africa.
The Fractional CFO and Interim CFO experiences gained by the executives assigned to these positions throughout Panterra Finance offer them a broad perspective of the dynamic changes in international markets. The part-time CFO executives at Panterra Finance have access to worldwide teams that are proficient in and have initiated innovative strategies in projects centered on Defi, Blockchain, Bitcoin, Ethereum, Crypto, and Tokenization services.
If you feel your business could benefit from Fractional CFO services, we invite you to book a call by clicking the below button. It could transform your business.